The Settlement Roadmap

Minimise stress, delay and legal fees.

Stage 3

Negotiating

Time to Engage

If you’ve done your preparation homework, it’s time to take a deep breath and actually engage in negotiation with your ex.

Preparing To Negotiate

Before we get into negotiation strategies and tactics, here are the two fundamental perspectives you need to lock in.

Remember what we said in earlier Guides? Your settlement will not be decided by “the law”. There’s a a myriad of factors that will influence your outcome. So don’t rely on a lawyer (or court) to get it sorted.

Read this Guide

6 minute read

Since there are basically no rules about who gets what, and no formal processes you must follow, then what factors really influence your settlement negotiation?

Read this Guide

15 minute read

Pathways

Tthere are multiple ways you can go about negotiating, so it's crucial to learn the pros and cons and implications, before you decide which path to take.

There are five common pathways to a settlement, each with very different pros and cons. We’ll review them, with particular attention to “who makes the decision?”

Read this Guide

10 minute read

It’s natural to expect some kind of orderly progression towards settlement — information is exchanged, proposals are made, and things gradually come together. Ha! You wish…

Read this Guide

6 minute read

Engaging in Negotiation Directly

Since about half of all people negotiate and settle their financial arrangements directly with their ex, well, let's work through the best way you can do that, too. [We'll talk through other ways of negotiating - like mediation, lawyers, court - in future Guides.]

At some point, someone needs to put forward a proposal. There’s immense benefit to you if you take the time to generate one in writing. We’ll talk you through all the reasons you should do that, then guide you through how.

Read this Guide

15 minute read

If it’s time to actually engage in negotiation, the big question is whether you will do so face-to-face. It may be daunting, but there are some strong reasons to at least try. Let’s check them out.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

If you’ve decided you’ll talk it through with your ex, you should be prepared. We’ll take you through our recommended agenda and a few tips.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

OK, so you summoned up the courage to try discussing the settlement directly with the ex. Let’s reflect on what you learned, so you can factor that into your next steps.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

How to Keep it Amicable - or at least Civilised

This is the single most powerful thing you can do to secure a reasonable settlement.

Keeping it amicable is the best way to end up with a fair and reasonable settlement. Easier said than done. Here are some perspectives that will help.

Read this Guide

12 minute read

More ways to keep your negotiation civilised, with particular focus on your decision-making perspectives.

Read this Guide

6 minute read

Support is available if you need it

Negotiating is never easy. If you need some support, check out the options at the bottom of this page.

Negotiation Strategies

Many factors will affect your ability to reach a fair deal. Work through these carefully to maximise a positive outcome.

There are several strategy issues and opportunities when negotiating a settlement. Let’s start with an overview of the core issues.​

Read this Guide

8 minute read

Settlements don’t usually happen in one “round”. There will be initial proposals and various counterpropositions. But with perseverances (and some goodwill if you can muster it), a deal will likely emerge.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Usually there are three to five key “needs” that are driving the other person’s priorities. If you’re in a position to enable or block those desires, you have leverage.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

If you’ve decided you’ll talk it through with your ex, you should be prepared. We’ll take you through our recommended agenda and a few tips.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Yes, sure, people do say “everything is in the pool – so it doesn’t matter whose name each asset is held in – it all comes out in the wash.” Well, that’s just plain naive. Let’s think this one through more carefully.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

It’s very common that one party doesn’t provide complete financial disclosure. It is possible to reach a settlement anyway? Yes, happens all the time. You just need to understand the trade-offs.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

As you’ve seen from our other Guides, family law has essentially no rules. So if you’re negotiation is stalled or drifting, tabling the Court option can shake things up.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

In your settlement negotiation, almost certainly, there will be a tension in your mind between digging your heels in versus showing some flexibility. How can you decide when to stand firm?

Read this Guide

5 minute read

Timing is often a much bigger factor than you might expect. A proposal might be rejected one month and accepted two months later. Let’s think about how timing may impact on you and on your ex.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

There will most likely come a point where you need to consider the emotional and logistical benefit of “cutting a deal”. Sometimes “good enough” should be your standard, rather than “perfect”.

Read this Guide

4 minute read

Settlement Deal Examples

As we've said, there are numerous ways your settlement deal could be structured. Here are just a few scenarios. (We'll be adding more shortly.)

Settlement negotiations are rarely reached in a single discussion. Across several rounds the parties normally move – gradually – to an acceptable point in between their initial views. Perfectly normal.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

The higher income earner may say they contributed more and so deserve more. But if the lower earner took on other duties (like primary carer), then that tends to swing the balance the other way.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Quite aside from what each person thinks is “fair”, it’s often the case that one party has greater urgency. That can materially alter that party’s willingness to compromise.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Usually big factors – like incomes, contributions, care of children – are major drivers in settlement outcomes. But sometimes health care – for one party or dependents – can significantly shift the result.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

If you’ve decided you’ll talk it through with your ex, you should be prepared. We’ll take you through our recommended agenda and a few tips.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Parenting

Fair and Reasonable focuses exclusively on financial settlements. But here are some basics about parenting you should make sure you're familiar with.

The core of all parenting negotiations with your ex must be centred on the best interests of the children. If you commit to that, there are some standard parent arrangements that you can implement.

Read this Guide

10 minute read

Your Headspace

No doubt there are many voices and opinions. But ultimately only you can decide what's in your best interest.

It’s understandable that you might feel you’re being treated unfairly, but fixating on it won’t help. In this Guide we’ll examine why a shift in your thinking can help deliver a better outcome.

Read this Guide

10 minute read

Yes. But only you can decide. There are plenty of reasons you might consider it. Let’s look at the 7 key factors that could lead you to conclude it’s the right decision for you.

Read this Guide

10 minute read

The way the rest of your journey evolves will depend on how each of you handle the negotiation. Here are some more tips on how to keep your strategy (and your head) clear as your settlement progresses.

Read this Guide

7 minute read

Support for this Stage

Most separating people seek some assistance in this negotiation phase. That's pretty normal. Here are some options:

Negotiation Support

Savvy guidance on negotiation dynamics and tactics (insight lawyers don’t usually provide).

Best for: Individuals who want insight and anticipation of their ex’s moves and how to orchestrate a fair outcome.

Fee: $300 +GST per hour.

Creating Proper Structure

Transforming your loose agreed deal into concise, workable terms.

Best for: Couples who agree in rough terms what they want, but need it calmly managed to a clear conclusion.

Fee: $350 +GST.

Rapid Settlement Service

A bidding process, based on recommended deal parameters and managed compromise.

Best for: Looking for the voice of experience to cut through confusion and outline a rational deal structure.

Fee: $500-$1,000 +GST (ie $250-$500 +GST per person)

Shuttle Mediation

An in-depth process where you both work with an independent mediator.

Best for: Couples looking for a civilised, managed process to keep the calm and achieve a result with the least stress.

Fee: $1,000-$2,500 +GST (ie $500-$1,250 +GST per person)

Find the answers you're looking for?

There are plenty more Guides in our other Stages: Understanding, Preparing, and Finalising.

We’re also continuously adding more Guides. If you didn’t find the info or understanding you need, ask us what you want to know.

We’ll create a Guide on the subject (usually within 48 hours). And we’ll email a copy to you personally.

Insights and Strategies You Won't Find Anywhere Else

We help separating people negotiate and formalise financial settlements.

Unlike law firms, we focus on practical, real-world methods and strategies.

Our Roadmap Guides provide crucial insights into how settlements really work, not in naive and fantasy-laden ways you might read about elsewhere.

Our Services provide unique, highly effective help to get you to a fair outcome – at minimal expense.

And our Community offers you shared insights and support from over 7,000 other Members.

Scroll to Top
Terms and Conditions

By using the Fair and Reasonable site and reading its content, you agree with the following Terms and Conditions:

  1. Fair and Reasonable provides information and views about financial settlements
  2. We do not provide information or views about parenting matters.
  3. We also do not provide information or views about court processes.
  4. Although we publish all information in good faith to assist users in forming views about the settlement process, we do not warrant the accuracy of every statement.
  5. We are not lawyers and Fair and Reasonable is not a law firm. We do not provide legal advice of any kind whatsoever, whether published on our website or in emails to you. Information and opinions expressed in this site are not specific to you or your situation or to any user’s particular situation.
  6. We invite users to become registered members of the site. The only data we collect about you are your email address and first name if you choose to become a registered member. We will not reveal your first name or email address details to any other party without your express written (digital) confirmation.
  7. We may recommend third party services to users and may have referral arrangements with some such providers.
  8. If you purchase services from Fair and Reasonable, those services may be subject to additional terms and conditions. 
  9. If you purchase services from Fair and Reasonable, you may choose to make payment by credit card. We use Stripe to process credit card payments. That means we do not ever obtain or see or record any of your credit card details.
  10. We invite you to propose topics for additional guides, but we do not commit to act on all such requests.
  11. If you provide us your email address, you consent to receiving emails from us from time to time. You can unsubscribe at any time using the unsubscribe button at the bottom of the emails.
  12. If we communicate with you by email or any other means, our communication does not purport to be and does not constitute legal or financial advice. If you need legal advice, you agree that you will seek it from a qualified lawyer. If you need financial advice, you agree that you will seek it from a person or firm with relevant financial skills and qualifications.
  13. You agree that you hold Fair and Reasonable harmless for any and all consequences of you relying upon any information provided by Fair and Reasonable, whether as published on our website or provided by email or any other form of communication with you. You indemnify Fair and Reasonable against any and all actions or damages you may incur or be exposed to in any manner whatsoever.
  14. We may utilise third party technology tools to enable services such as membership registration, appointment bookings, interactive forums. You are responsible for entering any information into such systems.
  15. We do not guarantee the availability of Fair and Reasonable at any time. You hold us harmless for any technological issues that prevent the continuous availability of the site.
  16. We may modify these Terms and Conditions at any time. You may review them at any time. You agree that we are under no obligation to advise you of any such changes.  
  17. By using and continuing to use Fair and Reasonable, you acknowledge and agree with all the above terms. You agree they apply to you regardless of whether you register as a member or log in as a member on any visit to the Fair and Reasonable site or view Fair and Reasonable without registering as a member.

Ask for access to this Guide

Ask to read our Advanced Guides

Just enter your details below and press Submit.

We’ll redirect you to the Advanced Guides – just wait a moment. 

And we’ll also email you a link so you can access the Advanced Guides again whenever you want.

Login

Not yet a member? Join now.